Back in the 1980s when The Evil Dead (1981), A Clockwork Orange (1971) and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974) were still banned in Britain by the then draconian BBFC and the 1984 Video Recordings Act, there were a lot of films floating around which gained an audience, not because they were any good, but because they had been removed from the shelves and were no longer available to rent or purchase in their original form.
In those days – when pornography was like gold dust and television almost exclusively family friendly – the pirate trade of these so called “Video Nasties” was about as taboo as you could get. If you did manage to secure an illicit copy of one of these films then you achieved instant hero status amongst your horror movie aficionados.
One of the few “Holy Grails” of this era was Meir Zarchi’s 1978 rape fantasy revenge flick I Spit on Your Grave. Few people actually saw the film at the time of its release, but those that had spoke in hushed whispers about its explicit scenes of gore and graphic violence – particularly the infamous castration scene, which when discussed caused much crossing of legs amongst the gents.
When a copy finally came my way I was of course bitterly disappointed. Rather than being a classic of the genre, in my opinion it was a cheap and almost unwatchable series of tortures, graphic but nowhere near as bad as popular mythology suggested. I’m sure there are some horror historians who would disagree, but as far as I’m concerned it was a waste of good celluloid and unworthy of its mystique.
When I heard about Steven R. Monroe’s remake, I freely admit that it was only morbid fascination that dragged me along to the screening. However, I was expecting a better film then the original and in all honesty it is (but only just).
The premise is simple: writer Jennifer (Sarah Butler) is taking time out in a cabin hideaway before she is affronted by a bunch of slack-jawed, disturbed locals who tease, traumatize and eventually rape her. She manages to escape and returns to seek her revenge by murdering her attackers in a variety of elaborate, unpleasant and highly improbable ways.
On the plus side, Monroe’s I Spit on Your Grave is well shot and credit should be given to the director for making the best of a relatively meagre $1.5 million budget. Butler is also perfectly fine in the lead role and might just have a promising future in film. However, aside from these positives, we are simply left with an hour or so of old fashioned torture porn.
There are those who will make claims that both Zarchi’s original and Monroe’s remake are trying to say something profound about feminism and gender politics, but those that do are probably on the production company payroll. You may try to read between the lines and look for allegory or meaning, but you would probably get the same results as you would reading through the telephone directory.
To conclude, if your idea of a hot Saturday night is a bit of rape and torture then the remade I Spit on Your Grave will be right up your alley. As for the rest of the cinema going public, I advise you avoid the film like the plague.